I learned of “We’re All Different But We’re All Kitty Cats: First Day of School” after writing “Bullying in Arizona: 11 Who Took a Stand” for Raising Arizona Kids Magazine. The book by Peter J. Goodman features illustrations by Nicolás Milano. It’s written for children ages 3 & up, and published by dreamBIG Press in Washington, DC.
DreamBIG books are meant to “bring adults and kids together” for conversations about “important social issues” early in children’s development. The “We’re All Different But We’re Kitty Cats” series addresses “topics that relate to developing social and emotional skills.” Each book ends with questions designed to jumpstart child/parent dialogue.
I was most impressed by its treatment of children’s emotional lives. When a mother cat in Meowville asks her son Carlos whether he’s excited about the first day of school, he tells her he’s nervous. “It’s okay to be nervous,” she tells him — showing that she’s both listening to his concerns and respecting his feelings.
Once Carlos gets to school, he joins fellow kitties in Miss Bobsie’s class. The teacher starts by asking students to “say your name and tell us two things about yourself.” Miss Bobsie goes first, sharing that she likes to wear funky glasses and that her favorite color is green.
Dylan has a bushy tail and likes playing tennis. Allie has yellow eyes and like having tea parties. There’s a class clown named Sammy, a kitty who likes scooters (he needs a helmet) and another who plays dress up with her friend Marla. Vinny has several sibs and a fondness for football.
Carlos tells the class he likes books, but hesitates before sharing his second fact. “I have no fur,” says Carlos. The class laughs. Carlos cries. We never see how the teacher reacts, but a pair of little girl cats discuss the episode while walking home. One says she feels bad and another adds that they “didn’t mean to make him cry.”
When they see Vinny bullying Carlos, Flo and Marla intervene — illustrating the concept of being an “upstander” rather than a bystander. Carlos gets home safely and talks with his mom about the day’s events. She points out his many special qualities, saying “One day you’ll see how special you are.”
The next day, Carlos returns to school — where he’s lauded by the class for knowing the full alphabet. We all want our kids to be smart, and hope they’ll never feel tempted to dummy themselves down to fit in with peers. In this sense, I suppose, what transpires during alphabet lessons reinforces something lots of parents value.
Still, one of my college-age children — inspired to explore the book by its striking cover design and illustrations — felt this segment of the story lacked realism. When classmates are bullies, she reminded me, showing your smarts rarely compels their conversion. In the end, the book’s resolution feels too easy and swift.
But like all books, we needn’t agree with every word to find their value. Both the book’s illustrations and plot points make intriguing topics of conversation — and it’s a perfectly enjoyable choice for parents of preschoolers who favor simple storytelling over morality tales. I was pleased as a cat owner to find “fun facts about kitty cats” noted on one of the book’s final pages.
The book series website features bullying prevention and humane education resources, games and activities for children, and tips for parents and teachers. While kids may return again and again to the book’s pages, I suspect plenty of parents will find the website a more valuable tool.
I’ll be watching for future titles in the “We’re All Different But We’re All Kitty Cats” series, which will tackle empathy, illness and loss, independence, making and losing friends, confidence and more.
“A Trip to the Big City,” the second title in the series, is scheduled for Spring 2013 release. Its cover shows seven kitty cats, including Carlos, standing amidst the bright lights of Broadway (with a sign for the musical “Cats” in the background).
Though I was dismayed to see the “First Day of School” kitty cats wearing backpacks slung over a single shoulder, I’m happy to share the author’s assurance that “No kitty cats were harmed or feelings hurt while making this book.”
— Lynn
Coming up: Best art books for kids, Dance meets bullying prevention, The fine art of literacy, Generations joined by art