One porch, four people. That’s the deal for most of David Auburn’s “Proof,” a play that considers family foibles in the context of mental illness. There’s a dad whose mathematical genius falls prey to disorganized thinking, a daughter whose talents get tucked away while caring for her father, a sister who vacillates between avoiding family problems and swooping in to fix them, and a man whose life intersects with all three.
“Proof” earned the 2001 Tony Award for best play and a Pulitzer Prize in drama, and was produced during the 2002/3 season by Arizona Theatre Company. I first saw the piece performed by ATC at the Herberger Theater Center in Phoenix, and admit it felt a rather dizzying affair. We were in the grips of dealing with mental illness close to home, which has a way of clouding everything you see and do.
So I was thrilled to get a second chance to experience the work on stage during Saturday night’s performance of “Proof” at Theatre Artists Studio in Scottsdale. They’re presenting an “Equity Members’ Project Code Production,” which gives Actors’ Equity Association members eager to hone and spotlight their talents a chance to mount works together for local audiences.
“Proof,” directed by Dominik Rebilas, is being performed at Theatre Artists Studio through November 4. Rebilas plays mathematics student Hal, shares sound design duties with Terry Youngren Hanson, and tackles set design for this production. He’s the sole cast member who’s not a member of AEA. Other cast members are Tony Hodges (Robert), Lesley Ariel Tutnick (Catherine) and Andrea Dovner (Claire).
Though the set for “Proof” is perfectly lovely, featuring windows with neatly symmetrical sections that convey the precision of mathematical musings, it feels a bit too polished. Only a pair of dead plants on tidy trellises hint at the decaying mind of the man who lives in the house shared by a daughter not prone to perfect housekeeping. A grittier, edgier set — with less uniformely bright lighting — would better demonstrate the darkness in these characters’ lives.
Though I didn’t feel much of the tension present when people grapple with their own or others’ symptoms, this production of “Proof” elevates another aspect of the play I hadn’t fully appreciated the first time around — family dynamics. This cast nimbly executes the verbal and physical language of everyday dysfunction. Think boundary issues and beyond. You don’t need experience with mental illness to appreciate this production. Having a family will do the trick.
Despite the sometimes dark subject matter, this piece is rife with humor — including plenty of one-liners. Some of the best riffs poke fun at pasta, student/teacher relationships, regional quirks of NYC and Chicago types, and rumored math geek pastimes.
But “Proof” raises serious questions too. Why are some fields so dominated by men? How much of who we are is inherited? How much should children sacrifice when caring for a parent? Can proof substitute for trust? Is making muffins a recipe for recovery?
The play also demonstrates ways that mathematical, scientific thinking informs problems populated by people rather than numbers. Think backing off a problem and returning to it later with fresh eyes.
The production staff for “Proof” includes Lorraine Bousard (assistant director, stage manager, props), Joe Bousard (original music) and the cast (costumes). Periodic bursts of piano music capture the changing moods of various characters, but would have been more effective played live on a piano set within or beside the set. In mathematics-speak, live music would have been “more elegant.”
As the holiday season approaches, “Proof” is a perfect reminder of the perils punctuating family gatherings. Those who rock the passive aggressive vibe should grab the most dysfunctional family members they can find, and take them along for an evening of “Proof.” It’s said that laughter is the best medicine, but laughing at ourselves just might be the cure.
— Lynn
Note: Click here for information on “The Time of Our Lives,” a Theatre Artists Studio fundraiser taking place at 6pm on Saturday, Nov. 10.
Coming up: The best meatpies in London
Updated with photos 10/22/12